As a reader and as an
author, I appreciate a good 5-star review! Since I know just how valuable
book reviews are on Amazon, Goodreads, and other book-related sites, I make an
effort to leave reviews for books that I’ve read. I read a wide variety of
fiction and non, some Christian, some not, and I read books published
independently by people I know and I read some best-sellers. I make every
effort to leave a review for books by newly published or indie authors.
I worry about
offending people with a less-than-perfect review. It has felt like an unspoken
obligation that I must hand out 5 stars to a person who I might see face-to-face
one day, or they might be mad at me! Let me tell you a few things from an
author’s perspective, and explain why I’m re-setting my standard here at the
beginning of 2017.
All reviews are vital.
The bottom line is that I’m grateful for every Amazon review left for my books,
even that 1-star review that simply said “hated it.” (In fact, I celebrated
when I saw that review appear. “I’m a legitimate author now!”) I know that my
books will go much further when I have a lot more reviews, so I’m thankful for
every single one.
Authors need reviews,
both good and bad, to provide feedback and illustrate the quality of our work. When I was in school, I didn’t expect
to get straight A’s for both the good and the bad, especially if my assignments
were being judged on whether or not the reader “liked” it. I received a variety
of grades in high school and college – and it didn’t kill me. Receiving lower
grades motivated me to do better next time. As a writer, if I get a number of
bad reviews, I know that I need to improve with my next project.
It’s not hard to
review a book. Log into your Amazon account, find the product, and scroll down until you
see the reviews. Click on the box that says “leave a product review.” Type a
few words, click on the stars, and you’re done!
As I look at other
people’s book reviews (especially on Goodreads, a helpful social media app
for readers), I realize that everyone rates books differently. Here’s my
system:
 |
| Authors always appreciate reviews on Amazon.com! |
4 stars: a good
book that I enjoyed and was written well enough
3 or 2 stars: probably had a hard
time holding my attention, a story I really didn’t like, or was poorly written
(unfortunately, many self-published or small-publisher-house books are not very
well written)
1 star: I’m not sure I’ll ever give
1 star, because if it’s that bad I probably put the book down and forgot about
it.
Saving the best for
last… 5 stars:
instead of giving
5-star reviews because I feel obligated to, going forward I’ll be holding the
honor of 5-star reviews a little tighter,
only giving them to books that do not have glaring grammatical problems or spelling errors,
and to books that leave an impact. For me, a 5-star book is one that is one of
two combinations: very well written + held my attention + I couldn’t put it
down. Or it’s a book that left a huge impact on me + it was well written.
Writer friends,
consider it a great honor to receive 5 stars from me! If I give you 4 stars,
know that I truly liked your book! If you’re a reader, consider creating your
own system of how you want to give out stars, and follow it by reviewing as
many books as you can! Remember that any review is a tremendous blessing to an
independent or newly published author.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
If you’re curious, here are books that I consider worthy of
all 5 stars! Starting with examples of books that left a huge impact on me + were well written, worthy of five stars:
Filming
God: A Journey from Skepticism to Faith by Darren Wilson was full of
faith-building messages I needed to hear last summer and it resonated deeply in
my heart.
Unplanned: The Dramatic True Story of a Former Planned Parenthood Leader’s
Eye-Opening Journey Across the Life Line by Abby Johnson rocked my
thinking of abortion and what it means to be pro-life.
These are just a couple of memoirs that impacted me greatly, especially in my
faith. I can think of a few more I would add to this list, including Choosing
to SEE: A Journey of Struggle and Hope by Mary Beth Chapman and Finding
Grace: A True Story About Losing Your Way in Life… And Finding It Again
by Donna VanLiere. Interestingly, although I love fiction, even the fictional
books that have impacted me haven’t made as great of an impression as reading
someone’s true and personal story. As I’ve grown as a writer, I’ve come to love
non-fiction, especially memoirs.
The Other 8 Hours: Maximize Your Free Time to Create New Wealth & Purpose by Robert Pagliarini, although non-fiction and not a memoir,
was a life-changing book for me. Using ideas and strategies from this book, I was
able to step out of being stuck in a cubicle to earning an income as a nanny (which
I enjoy so much more!) I kept using those strategies to become a published
author while keeping my day job as a nanny. Although it is a business book and
not my normal reading material, I really enjoyed reading this book and applying
what I learned.
Examples of books that were very well written + held my attention + I couldn’t put them down:
Far as the Curse is Found: Searching for God in Infertility,
Miscarriage, and Stillbirth by Abigail Waldron was carefully thought
out, it’s a topic near to my heart, and although it took me a longer time to
read than most, it impacted me greatly.
In Due Time: A Journey Through Infertility, Loss, and Embracing the
Unknown by Jen Noonan intrigued me. Although she and I dealt with our infertility
in very different ways, I loved reading her story and learning from it! This
book was very well-written and hard for me to put down.
How do you rate books? Tell me about a book you would give 5
stars!
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Hi, I’m Betsy, and I live in the Washington, D.C. area with my husband, Mike. We have been married
Thanks so much for reading my posts!